Obamacare, or the Affordable Care Act is causing one of the greatest United States legislative controversies since the advent of Medicare and Medicaid. What IS it? Read the following article, from the Washington Post, and post a comment, at the end. Please note that this article is not current, but it is a good overview of a very complicated issue. You may also draw on knowledge from other adults/resources, but your blog MUST show knowledge of this article. (Be sure to click on and read the blog directions, first!)
Facts about the Affordable Care Act
In the past week, both Alec MacGillis and Sabrina Tavernise have written articles touching on how little the uninsured actually know about the Affordable Care Act. Given that polling shows the law remains unpopular even as its component parts -- with the notable exception of the individual mandate -- are very popular, it seems they're not alone. So here's a refresher on some of the law's most significant policies and consequences:
1. By 2022, the Congressional Budget Office estimates (pdf) the Affordable Care Act will have extended coverage to 33 million Americans who would otherwise be uninsured. Here's the graph:
2. Families making less than 133 percent of the poverty line -- that's about $29,000 for a family of four -- will be covered through Medicaid. Between 133 percent and 400 percent of the poverty line -- $88,000 for a family of four -- families will get tax credits on a sliding scale to help pay for private insurance.
3. For families making less than 400 percent of the poverty line, premiums are capped. So, between 150% and 200% of the poverty line, for instance, families won't have to pay more than 6.3 percent of their income in premiums. Between 300 percent and 400 percent, they won't have to pay more than 9.5 percent. This calculator from the Kaiser Family Foundation will let you see the subsidies and the caps for different families at different income levels.
4. When the individual mandate is fully phased-in, those who can afford coverage -- which is defined as insurance costing less than 8 percent of their annual income -- but choose to forgo it will have to pay either $695 or 2.5 percent of the annual income, whichever is greater.
5. Small businesses that have fewer than 10 employees, average wages beneath $25,000, and that provide insurance for their workers will get a 50 percent tax credit on their contribution. The tax credit reaches up to small businesses with up to 50 employees and average wages of $50,000, though it gets smaller as the business get bigger and richer. The credit lasts for two years, though many think Congress will be pressured to extend it, which would raise the long-term cost of the legislation.
6. Insurance companies are not allowed to discriminated based on preexisting conditions. They are allowed to discriminate based "on age (limited to 3 to 1 ratio), premium rating area, family composition, and tobacco use (limited to 1.5. to 1 ratio)."
7. Starting in 2018, the law imposes a 35 percent tax on employer-provided health plans that exceed $10,200 for individual coverage and $27,500 for family coverage. The idea is a kind of roundabout second-best to capping the tax code's (currently unlimited) deduction for employer-provided heath insurance. The policy idea is to give employers that much more reason to avoid expensive insurance policies and thus give insurers that much more reason to hold costs down.
8. The law requires insurers to spend between 80 and 85 percent of every premium dollar on medical care (as opposed to administration, advertising, etc). If insurers exceed this threshold, they have to rebate the excess to their customers. This policy is already in effect, and insurers are expected to rebate $1.1 billion this year.
9. The law is expected to spend a bit over $1 trillion in the next 10 years. The law's spending cuts -- many of which fall on Medicare -- and tax increases are expected to either save or raise a bit more than that, which is why the Congressional Budget Officeestimates that it will slightly reduce the deficit. (There's been some confusion on this point lately, but no, the CBO has not changed its mind about this.) As time goes on, the savings are projected to grow more quickly than the spending, and CBO expects that the law will cut the deficit by around a trillion dollars in its second decade. Here's its graph, which covers the period between 2012 and 2021:
10. In recent years, health-care costs have slowed dramatically. Much of this is likely due to the recession. Some of it may just be chance. But there's also evidence that the law has accelerated changes in the way the medical system delivers care, as providers prepare for the law's efforts to move from fee-for-service to quality-based payments.
11. The law's long-term success at controlling costs will likely hinge on its efforts to change the way health care is delivered, most of which have gotten very little attention. They include everything from encouraging Accountable Care Organizations to spreading medical homes to penalizing hospitals with high rates of preventable infections to creating an independent board able to quickly implement new reforms through the Medicare system. A partial list of these efforts can be found here.
Acknowledgments: Much of the information in this post comes from the Kaiser Family Foundation's excellent summary of the Affordable Care Act's provisions.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2012/06/24/11-facts-about-the-affordable-care-act/
Ezra Klein is the editor of Wonkblog and a columnist at the Washington Post, as well as a contributor to MSNBC and Bloomberg. His work focuses on domestic and economic policymaking, as well as the political system that’s constantly screwing it up. He really likes graphs, and is on Twitter, Google+ and Facebook. E-mail him here.
Based on the facts in this article the Affordable Care Act shouldn't have been passed. The first reason is that in #2 it states that "families will get tax credits...to help pay for private insurance." The part that is bad about this is that the government is making people pay money to a private company, which is unconstitutional. It is also unfair for insurance companies to discriminate based on age (#6). In conclusion, the law is unconstitutional because congress is forcing citizens to enter an economic transaction with a private company. If you refuse to enter into a contract with a private company you will receive a "tax" penalizing you.
ReplyDelete--
Some extra points not in the article: It is also unconstitutional for the government to take control of one sixth of our economy, and everybody's health insurance will go up because health insurance companies will have to cover the preexisting sick (can't discriminate on preexisting conditions #6)
Due to the information presented in this article, Obamacare is proven to be somewhat beneficial. It does aid the uninsured greatly, for they now have healthcare, but it does not improve the economy. It decreases the amount of people without health care, but by raising taxes to such a degree, it does not benefit the people who can afford healthcare to begin with. Based on the negatives and positives mentioned of the Affordable Care Act, it helps some greatly, while it hinders some as well.
ReplyDeleteThe Affordable Care Act should be passed because of the benefits for small businesses. Having small businesses benefit from providing insurance will help their employees as well as the business itself. The money saved from the tax credit will help the business get off to a stronger economical start and allow it to grow. Employers will also be able to provide a better healthcare system to their employees because of the credit received. The employees will benefit, and as the business grows more jobs will be created and the economy will improve.
ReplyDeleteBen Ross History 84
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhat the Affordable Care Act is trying to do is decrease the percentage of the population that does not have health insurance. The government already is using Medicaid to support the percentage of the population below the poverty line with out health insurance. However, the percentage just over the poverty line originally had to pay for their health insurance. With the Affordable Care Act, the government supplies a small sum of money to help the population barely over the poverty line find affordable health insurance. It is almost like slightly increasing the boundaries of Medicaid.
ReplyDeleteAnother change brought with the Affordable Care Act is that insurance companies cannot refuse people insurance, as it is illegal. Even if a person has a history of cancer, they cannot be turned away by the companies. However, if the person has a history of smoking, the price of the insurance can be increased.
The money will mainly come from tax increases, and some of the funding and savings from Medicare (for the elderly) will be taken out and moved to Medicaid. The government will try to make Medicare more efficient, to save money, and those savings will go into Medicaid.
Zetty Cho - History 84
The Affordable Care Act should be passed. The first reason is that the act is helping small business. By helping them, the company will get a fifty percent tax credit. This is helping them by making small business expand a lot faster and easier.By doing this, it is also creating more and more jobs. It's creating jobs because as the company expands, it will need more employees. Another reason why the Affordable Care Act should be passes is because it is also helping the families that are below poverty line. In #3m it says, "between 150% and 200% of the poverty line... families won't have to pay more than 6.3 percent of their income in premiums." This is going to help the families because they will be able to pay less. The last reason is because the health-care cost has slowed dramatically. This will help every family because families won't have to pay as much for health care. These are the reason why the Affordable Care act should be passed.
ReplyDeleteThe Affordable Care Act should be passed. It makes sure that the lower class families will be given a better chance to afford the insurance they need. The article shown says that within ten years, we would have covered 33 million Americans who would not have been insured without it. For instance, if the family was in the 133% or lower of the poverty line, they would be covered with Medicaid. If a family was in the 133-400% range, they will receive tax credits to help pay for the insurance that they choose. Even without the tax credits, the families in the 150-400% range would not even have to pay 10% of their annual income for their health insurance. The Affordable Care Act should be passed for the benefit of our lower class citizens.
ReplyDeleteTayseer Chowdhury (History-84)
The Affordable Care Act should be passed mainly because discrimination for preexisting conditions isn’t allowed, it benefits small businesses greatly, and is priced based on income (percentage above poverty line). First, having discrimination for preexisting conditions be not allowed is a big part because those who cannot afford insurance but have a major health problem like cancer (Im using Zetty’s example) can still be covered. Secondly, small businesses get discounts on their tax credits, which make them happy, and their employees who are provided health insurance (from the small business) are happy as well. Finally, health insurance price is based on income, so the people who can’t afford it pay the least while the more rich people pay slightly higher prices. Although there are some downfalls, overall, it should be passed.
ReplyDeleteThe Affordable care act should be passed because it will help small businesses, cover more people than medicaid, and encourage companies to offer well-priced health insurance to their employees. Obamacare will help insure people who cannot afford health care, but do not meet the criteria to be covered by medicaid. As this article shows, in a few years, about 33 million Americans who would be uninsured without the Affordable care Act will be insured because of it. The only problem is that in putting this act in place, America will be losing about a trillion dollars. This is okay, though, because in number 9 of this article, there is a graph showing that America's deficit will greatly increase because of the Affordable Care act, but then it will even out over time. It will also probably decrease after a while because this will be helping small businesses do better.
ReplyDeleteElizabeth-History 84
The affordable care act should be passed because it help almost 33 million people who without it would be un-insured and it helps smalls businesses.Without medicaid those people would be un-insured, but with medicaid it also raises taxes. Raising taxes does not benefit those who could not afford it in the first place, but don't qualify to get medicaid. Agreeing with Elizabeth, (above) Obamacare helps to insure people who can't afford health care but it doesn't qualify to have medicaid. The Affordable Care act will help to decrease the amount of un-insured people and it will help small businesses.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the act should be passed. Like Michael said, it will help expand small businesses, and therefore create more jobs. Others above have said it will not discriminate against those who have long-term health issues, but to those who choose to be at risk (by smoking etc.). This is understandable because it is not your fault if you were diagnosed with cancer because it runs in your family. There is no prevention to that, but if you smoke you are putting yourself at risk for having cancer, but that is your own choice. I also agree with Delila that there are some cons for some people in this plan, as there are to every plan. It may not benefit those who can afford health care, but it does decrease the amount of people who can’t. I believe that it is important for everyone to have health care because there is no way to avoid injury or sickness, so I agree with others that the Affordable Act Care should be passed.
ReplyDeleteCarly 8-3
The Affordable Care Act is attempting to decrease the population without insurance, which seems like a desirable plan for people just above the poverty line, however there are some issues that come along with this plan. The goal of the Act is to ensure everyone with insurance, and a fine of either $695 or 2.5 percent of the yearly income (whichever number is higher) will be given to those who refuse to get insured. The fine may be a preferable alternate to those for whom the price of insurance is greater than the fine itself. Therefor the fine may be ineffective. For a family of four, the difference between the fine and the insurance could be (8% - 2.5%) 5.5 % of the annual income. If this family earns $80,000 a year, then it will have a choice to pay the fine or to pay $4400 more and be ensured. The question to see if this fine is effective is what will the family decide.
ReplyDeleteThe Affordable Care Act is the best way to decrease the uninsured population of the United States. There are downsides to the act, as not everybody would be protected, such as those who "choose to be at risk." I think the act needs to get away from some of the views that anybody who smokes is choosing to be at risk. A better idea would be to provide some amount of therapy for those who smoke or take other actions that damage their health. As far as the effectiveness of the fine, I agree with Maia that if it made financial sense, many families would rather pay the fine than get insurance. I think that this plan touches on all the right principles, but there are some small details that should be reconsidered.
ReplyDelete-Trevor Donovan 83
The Affordable care act should be passed because it will make coverage more affordable for low-income Americans and in the long run, benefit the economy. Millions of uninsured Americans will get access to affordable quality health insurance, and over half of them can get free or low cost health insurance using their State's Health Insurance Marketplace. It will also expand small businesses and increase jobs. Another advantage of Obamacare is that preventative services are free, so over time, it will lower health care costs by treating mild diseases before they become serious and very expensive. Although the Affordable Care Act is expected to cost over a trillion dollars, by curbing the growth in healthcare spending and ending unwarranted subsidies, in the long run, it will reduce the deficit, saving over $1 trillion in the second decade. As Carly stated, every plan has both pros and cons, but I believe that for Obamacare, the benefits outweigh the costs.
ReplyDelete-Michelle Tang, 83
I agree that the Affordable Care Act should be passed in order to increase the number of U.S. citizens with health insurance.Everyone should have access to health care, because that is humane and it also makes sense economically. If you have health insurance you are more likely to act to prevent problems and not wait until your health situation has gotten worse and therefore more expensive. Also, if somebody can't afford to take their sick child to a doctor, it's a pretty sad thing. Right now the very poorest can get Medicaid, but the somewhat less poor are often out of luck. This way, those people will be paying something, and taking responsibility, but they will get government help to afford health insurance. Also, anyone can lose their job, and without the Affordable Care Act, that would mean they would lose their health insurance, too. With the Affordable Care Act, if you decided to leave your job and start your own business, you could do that, and you would still have health insurance. Many people have preexisting conditions, and that shouldn't stop them from getting health insurance, as several other bloggers have pointed out.
ReplyDeleteThe government already has the Medicare program to give people over age 65 access to medical care. That program was started in 1965 because many senior citizens were too poor to afford health insurance, and when it began, a lot of people thought it was bad, but it is now very popular. Perhaps once the the Affordable Care Acts gets underway and gets the bugs worked out, it will also be quite popular.
#1. I believe that the Affordable Care Act or Obamacare shouldn't be passed because of its negative affect on businesses and workers. The Affordable Care Act proposes to make businesses pay for the health care of their employees. Now the businesses want to avoid this, so they cut the work time of their employees avoiding to pay for health care but in hand the employee has their salary cut along with their minutes. #2. The decisions of doctoring will be decided by the government choosing whether to provide special care to those in need. The government can turn down these needs simply because it will cost to much money. I personally believe that the health of our people should come before money. This plan merges the government with hospitals across the country. No one yet knows if the government is able to handle the health issue off every person within the nation. #3. Many Doctors and nurses say that they will leave practice if the Affordable Care Act is passed because they aren't able to make decisions without the consent of the government. If this act is put into place many doctors will leave hospitals leaving care centers with less ability to operate.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteHis 8-4
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThe affordable care act is a plan to make health care more affordable to Americans. The Affordable Care Act will have extended coverage to 33 million Americans who would otherwise be uninsured by the year 2022. The Affordable Care Act will also benefit families who are 150% and 200% of the poverty line. These families won't have to pay more than 6.3 percent of their income in premiums. The Affordable Care Act should be passed because of this. It will have a better long term effect on the country. The economy will be a little bit off at first because of the increase of taxes, but having more people healthy will lead to a better future with more money for the country. If the act is not passed there will still be many American people who will barely have enough to pay for health care, and after these people do pay they won't have any money left for food, gas, heat, or other things needed by the every day American.
ReplyDeleteI agree, the Affordable Care Act should be passed. Many opponents of Obamacare say that it places a large amount of strain on small businesses and those who are covered by the state. As pointed out by Obama during the election however, Mitt Romney, who caused significant push back on the plan, invented the concept used in the act and had it work out quite well in Massachusetts. One of the overlooked points of Romney's counter-arguments was that all the health care providers in Massachusetts are non-profit. He, along with many others, didn't like the idea of a one-size-fits-all plan. While this is a genuine argument, even more so after the website for switching plans crashed and burned this morning, it ignores a few key points. The amount of uninsured Americans is simply horrendous. The important thing about Obamacare is that it forces everyone to be insured, and not only that but insured well. There are naturally going to be a few kinks in the system to start out with since the plan doesn't grandfather people's current coverage. This is necessary because some of the plans that don't comply with federal requirements are plans that are too cheap to provide good coverage, which don't really count as health care. The one problem with the whole thing is that it wasn't very well explained. The issue was that the time to explain the act would have been when the election was coming up, and apparently Obama didn't even want to remind people about healthcare until he was safely reelected. Thus spawned the explanation of the plan that left out the part about some people who had health care having to switch providers. In a way, health care is very similar to auto insurance, both having the same concept of paying when everything is fine to pay for when there is an emergency. Using this analogy, Obama could have explained it to everybody because almost eighty five percent of Americans have insured cars, making it easy to understand. Once the act gets up and running, the amount of uninsured Americans will drastically decrease. However, seeing as Romney's similar plan in Massachusetts (already the most insured state in the country and had no immigration issues) took a year or two to start operating at its full potential, it could take a little while for Obamacare to have an impact.
ReplyDelete--O. Hakim, H-84
I agree that the Affordable Care Act should be passed. As it states in number one the Affordable Care Act will spread its coverage to 33 million Americans by 2022. Without this act these 33 million Americans would be uninsured. Number two states that for the families who are making less than 133 percent of the poverty line would be covered. For the families between 133 and 400 percent they would be given tax credits to help pay for their private insurance. This law also requires insurance payers to spend between 80 and 85 percent of every premium dollar on medical care as stated in number eight. In number eleven it says that the long term success of this act if passed will change the way that health care is delivered, most of this has gotten very little attention. Although passing this act will cause strain on small businesses I still believe that the Affordable Care Act should be passed.
ReplyDeleteJamie H, H-84
I would have voted for the bill because it is important for all people to have access to affordable health care. This arises the question; should poor people not have access to health care because they cannot afford it? The hardest part is to decide who really needs healthcare and who does not. The idea is a good one, and the intentions are good, but the implementation is often inefficient there are people who try to work the system, that don’t really need the help but will get benefits anyway from the help. It’s a difficult plan to implement because of people who cheat the system and this is a costly plan, but it is worth it for people with smaller incomes, who are in need of health care.
ReplyDelete-Cooper Wolff H-84
The Affordable Care Act is beneficial because, It would help small businesses to progress, people with preexisting conditions cannot be discriminated, and insurance companies can only take 15-20 % of premiums. Small businesses will receive a 50 percent tax credit, and reduces the Burdon on the business. People with preexisting conditions can’t be discriminated when signing up for healthcare. This is helpful to people who have strong medical needs, and will not leave any sick people uncovered. People can only be discriminated by their age, their tobacco use, where they live, and their family’s composition. Health insurance companies can only spend 15-20 % of a dollar for their operating costs. This way, health insurance will be less expensive. This law shows many different positives, as spoken above it keeps business in mind, insurance costs remain low, and finally this law is important because it does not allow the sick to be stranded without medical care.
ReplyDeleteIndia Cabot
History 8-4
I would vote for the bill because it is beneficial to those in need of support when it comes to their income. For example, the bill will help small businesses along in need of an income boost. It will not only help them build income but also guarantees to last, "The credit lasts for two years, though many think Congress will be pressured to extend it, which would raise the long-term cost of the legislation." This not only helps the owners of the business but it also helps the employees working for it. If the bill is accepted, owners of small businesses and their employees will have a better income, leaving the business less likely to go out of business. The bill also has a wide definition of what a small business is, based on how "small" the business really is the bill will treat it accordingly. For companies with fewer than ten employees will receive $25,000 in. The workers will also get at fifty percent tax credit on their contribution. The bill goes up to a business with less than fifty employees, they receive wages of $50,000, although it decreases as the business succeeds, getting larger and wealthier.
ReplyDelete-Kaitlyn Cohen
History 8-4
Based on the facts stated in this article Affordable care act the bill should be passed, as stated in many of the comments before. Obama care will be beneficial to Americans, especially to those above the poverty line, and will start to effect Massachusetts residents in the future, but it will take time. These families between 133 and 200 precent will be given aid to purchase private insurance. Obama care will not be beneficial to the economy, but will increase the amount of Americans with health insurance. It will be especially beneficial to small business employees providing a tax credit of fifty percent. Citizens will not be discriminated against by signing up for the plan, which promises the insurance companies will be given 15-20 percent of the of the premiums. The plan presented is very beneficial to the the future and will help America progress as a country and provide health care to those who are without it at this specific moment in time.
ReplyDeleteBrooke Shachoy
History 8-4
The facts in this article explain in an unbiased opinion why or why not the Affordable Care act should be passed. Based on this information I would vote for the act to be passed because it would be extremley beneficial to Americans and the American government because it would improve America's financial state. If there are less people in poverty then the American government will continue to improve. The graphs in the Article demonstrated that not only would the Affordable Care act help many people in poverty in the short term, but it would help the whole American community in the long run as well. The graph showed that by the year 2022 the act would give about 33 million people coverage that would have otherwise been in poverty. The citizens of America who are in poverty cannot afford health care and if this act is passed then that problem will over a short period of time, can be solved and continue to be solved for many years to come.
ReplyDeleteThe plan also will help people running small businesses by giving health care to it's workers that otherwise would not be able to have health care. Since the people running small businesses would barely be able to have health care themselves, they would not be making enough money through their business to give health care to all employees. The Affordable care act should be passed because it will help America's problem with health care for those in poverty.
Caroline Scheer
History 8-3
Overall the affordable care act (Obama care) bill should be passed because it allows 30 million people who would not be able to get the money to pay for a good healthcare plan to receive healthcare. Also, you can’t be denied coverage for preexisting conditions, meaning that, if you are sick and need healthcare to be able to afford the hospital visits then you were in trouble, because no healthcare company would want you as a costumer in the future because they have young healthy people who won’t get sick and will be better for the company. The only problems are that the affordable care act raises the cost for young healthy people who are less likely to get sick and lowers it for old people who are a lot more likely to get sick. This really bothers the young people because they end up paying for the healthcare when they don’t need it and the older people end up not paying for it as much when they need it more.
ReplyDeleteThe affordable care act should be passed due to the benefits of #6. This allows anyone with a pre-existing health impairment to get health insurance. Before, companies could turn away a customer with a life-threatening condition, which would strip the family of the customer of money that could be necessary for the survival of the customer. The law also allows companies to discriminate by tobacco use, which benefits those who have possibly made better health choices than others. This gives a fair ground to those who chose not to handicap themselves by using tobacco. However, this pro could also be a con, because it allows companies to discriminate by age, which affects a large percentage of the us population.
ReplyDelete